• Skip to main content
  • Skip to secondary menu
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Home
  • About
  • Topics
    • CBT
    • CHANGES
    • Clinical Depression
    • Anxiety
    • Motivational Interviewing
    • Alcohol
    • Goal Setting
    • MBTI
    • Running
    • Interviews
  • Podcast
  • Contact

Finding My Psych

Mastering Applied Health Psychology and Behavioural Medicine

Mastering Applied Health Psychology & Behavioural Medicine

A Model for Improved Mental Health Through Evidence-Based Clinical Practice and Research

  • Psychology
  • Fitness
  • Nutrition
  • Addiction
  • Episodes
  • General
You are here: Home / Episodes / FMP 022 • Plant-Based Advocates vs The Anti-Vaccination Movement (The Evidence)

FMP 022 • Plant-Based Advocates vs The Anti-Vaccination Movement (The Evidence)

January 25, 2020 By Jerod Killick, M.S.

Podcast: Play in new window | Download

“Health Psychology is naturally in alignment with a plant-based diet – There is no room for the anti-vaccination movement”

Podcast show focusing on vegans and anti-vaccination

Finding My Psych Takes a Stand

At Finding My Psych, we promote a plant-based diet as part of a holistic approach to wellness. We in no way want to be associated with such fringe perspectives as the anti-vaccination movement.

The anti-vaccination movement is attempting to align itself with the plant-based movement, in particular, veganism. While a very small minority of vegans subscribe to ill-informed anti-vax beliefs, it is important for plant-based advocates of any kind, differentiate themselves from such radical ideas – The plant-based lifestyle will never be seen as a legitimate health alternative to the mainstream if this association solidifies.

Understanding the Empirical and Psychological Arguments

In today’s episode we review the importance of using science to understand the conclusions we make. With that said, we believe that every listener should commit to studying research methods in order to grasp a full understanding why the science does not back anti-vaccination arguments.

We discuss various thought errors and distortions often used to support fringe beliefs, regardless of the position of the person making the argument. While the topic of confirmation bias is regularly noted, we expand our conceptualization by providing an understanding of:

  • All or Nothing Thinking
  • Confusion of Causation and Correlations in Arguments
  • Emotional Reason to Support Beliefs

Episode Outline

Introduction
  • Welcome New Listeners
Engaging With Others at FMP
  • Community Portal
    • Topics on fitness, emotional well-being, mental health, and addiction.
    • You can also provide feedback about content you would like included in future episodes and articles.
Today’s Topic:
  • A plant-based and/or vegan lifestyle is not congruent with the anti-vaccination movement
  • I made some anti-vaccination folks mad at me on twitter this week.
  • Defining The Problem
    • Finding My Psych supports and promotes a plant-based lifestyle for health and wellness.
      • This has come at a cost because of an association with a loud and radical minority.
    • Those believing in the anti-vaccination movement are attempting to attach themselves to plant-based and vegan advocates as a way to promote the, “clean vs. unclean” concept.
    • Anti-vaccination proponents arguments similar to those defending religious beliefs.
      • Plant-based and vegan advocates open themselves up to this association due to the same argument pattern.
  • What is the plant-based/vegan movement?
  • What is the anti-vaccination movement?
    • Start with an understanding that individuals have good intentions.
    • Promoted by celebrity and online marketing strategies designed to get clicks (Google).
  • Why is a plant-based/vegan lifestyle and the anti-vaccination movement not comparable?
    • It’s a matter of science
      • Dr. Dean Ornish heart disease research vs. Autism Studies lacking evidence.
    • It’s a matter of psychology
      • **Some vegans fall into this too when promoting products.  
      • All or nothing thinking
        • The clean vs unclean debate.
        • Vegan purity junkies – “You must draw the line somewhere.”
      • Confusing Causation with Correlation
        • Symptoms on autism start so show around the same months as the MMR vaccination series.  Correlation is seen as causation.
      • Emotional Reasoning
        • Sharing tragic stories of loss and linking with the most available explanation, vaccinations.  People then tend to share the tragic story to back up their belief, thus discounting data, or the lack of it.
Final Thoughts
  • The vegan movements own problem with all or nothing thinking sets itself up to be associated with the anti-vaccination movement.
  •  

You Might Also Like

  • FMP 023 • The Psychology of Coping During Recovery Mode from COVID19

    "There will be a day when we no longer have to stand in line." Emerging From Disaster - Entering Recovery Mode In today's episode, we…

  • FMP 001 • Introducing the Finding My Psych Podcast

    Welcome to, "The Finding My Psych Podcast!" Time For A Launch Party! We are so proud to announce the launch of our new podcast venture,…

  • FMP 025 • On Plant-Based Living and Caution To Vegans During The Pandemic

    "It comes down to personal choice." Why Finding My Psych Promotes a Plant-Based Lifestyle In today's episode we discuss the rationale for why the Finding…

Filed Under: Episodes

Listen to the Finding My Psych Podcast

Apple PodcastsGoogle PodcastsSpotifyPandoraStitcherTuneInRSSMore Subscribe Options

About Jerod Killick, M.S.

Jerod Killick received his masters degree in Clinical Psychology in 1997, and later completed a post-graduate clinical and research concentration in Behavioural Medicine and Health Psychology.  He currently works as a senior leader in mental health and addictions for Vancouver Coastal Health.

Primary Sidebar

Listen On Spotify

Listen to the Finding My Psych Podcast

Featured Author: Liz Garrett

My Best Life by Liz Garrett

Crisis Resources

If you are in emotional distress, please consider contacting one of the following international resources:

  1. CASP/ACPS Suicide Crisis Centres (Canada)
  2. Your Life Counts – Crisis Line Near You (International)
  3. National Suicide Prevention Lifeline (USA) – 1-800-273-8255
  4. Crisis Text Line 24/7 (USA) – 741741

**If you are in crisis and do not feel safe, contact a local mental health professional or go directly to the nearest emergency department.

Copyright © 2018-2021 All Rights Reserved: Finding My Psych - Mastering Applied Health Psychology and Behavioural Medicine, Jerod Killick, M.S., Vancouver, BC. Canada